Reading Mother Tongue by Amy Tan was an example of how she
grew up with her mother who spoke poor English, but to her seemed almost
perfectly clear. It was HER mother tongue. Amy went through all her life
hearing how her mother spoke and it was natural to her. Amy quotes later on
that she catches herself saying, "Not waste money that way." This
language was what was familiar to her, but to other people was broken English. This
memoir was meaningful to me because I can relate in a way where some of my family
and I have our own mother tongue. Most of my family beyond my parents is
Italian and my Uncle actually came to Ellis Island when he was 15 from Italy.
When we are all together we speak English but we say some words in Italian. For
instance when we greet each other, we kiss on the cheek and my Uncle always
says "Ah, Mi Amor," which means my love and I see that as normal. I
look at that as MY mother tongue although other people may not understand. I
never saw it as anything different because that was how I grew up and how I was
taught. The theme in Mother Tongue is how versatile language can be. There is not
one, correct definition for a mother tongue because everyone grows up
differently. Then purpose Amy Tan
tries to convey is that what you grow up with and what you are used to
doesn't always mean its right. There is a lot of realization in this story and
how she picks up on her broken mother tongue that she never knew was broken. Mother Tongue conveys a great message that could apply to a lot of people and it made me realize that I also had a mother tongue.
Hey Gabrielle, I definitely agree with what you had to say about Mother Tongue. I appreciated you explaining that there is not just one definition for a mother tongue or what it is, because everyone grows up differently. And I agree that this concept of language that Amy Tan explains should be applied to more people. Good Job!
ReplyDeleteI like how you took examples from your life and compared it to the story. It gives it a human feeling other than just reading it and thinking oh well that's cool. The way you responded to the story was great and i enjoyed hearing what you had to say about it.
ReplyDeleteHey Gabrielle,I enjoyed reading your Blog. I completely agree with you, specially when you said that "what you grow up with and what you are used to doesn't always mean its right." I can relate to "Mother Tongue" as well as you because of my Spanish family. Nice job!
ReplyDelete